This story begins on Instagram with a new follower who claimed to be a fantasy writer just starting out in creative writing. I followed back. Why not?
“She” posted many times a day, almost always carousels. For someone “new” to creative writing, she sure had a lot of advice, including this little nugget:
Tbh, 90% of the time, writer’s block is actually a plot problem.
Umm…no.
I clicked on the “writer’s” Instagram profile, did about five minutes of digging, and sure enough. The whole profile was AI-generated.
All the same, real human writers still saw this message, and I want to talk about it.
I’ve been on the receiving end of similar advice dozens of times during the periods I’ve been blocked: “Just use a beat sheet,” “spend more time on your outline,” “follow your character’s arc.” I plotted and re-plotted my first novel using four different methods and still couldn’t write it.
That’s because writer’s block and plot problems are not the same.
First, if you’re a fiction writer, plot problems are an occupational hazard. Your early drafts are supposed to have plot problems because you’re still uncovering what the plot is. This is where beat sheets, character arcs, and outlines are helpful because they are designed to help you uncover your plot and subplots.
Second, identifying plot problems and experimenting with solutions are signs that drafting is going well! Is this a fun part of the process? Not for everyone (it’s me, hi), and it can take a long time to untangle the knots your characters wove. You might feel blocked because your word count slows down, but every knot you untangle is progress.
Finally, writer’s block is a symptom of a larger problem such as perfectionism, burnout, or rejection sensitivity. When I tried different plotting methods to fix my writer’s block, my perfectionism said, “See? You still aren’t good enough to write this story." My block only grew heavier until I walked away from that story altogether for two and half years.
Of course it’s possible for writer’s block and plot problems to coexist. But equating writer’s block and plot problems is, at best, a misunderstanding. At worst, calling your block a “plot problem” will make your block heavier and harder to deal with.
Don’t take advice from robots, friends. Your plot problems are legitimate, and so is your writer’s block. But they do not have the same solution.